Find the fake coin puzzle
๐ก
Given 11 identical coins but there's a fake coin which has different weight to the others, identify it with 3 trials. Try the simulation game here
Demo
Solution
To be convenience for explanation, we number all 11 coins from 1 to 11.
1,2,3 = 4,5,6 (1,2,3,4,5,6 are real):
1,2,3 =7,8,9 (7,8,9 are real)
1 = 10 (10 is real) => 11 fake
1 <> 10 => 10 fake
1,2,3 > 7,8,9 (either 7,8,9 is fake, lighter)
7 = 8 (8 is real) => 9 fake
7 > 8 => 8 fake
7 < 8 => 7 fake
1,2,3 < 7,8,9 (either 7,8,9 is fake, heavier)
7 = 8 (8 is real) => 9 fake
7 > 8 => 8 fake
7 < 8 => 7 fake
1,2,3 < 4,5,6 (7,8,9,10,11 are real)
1,2,3 = 7,8,9 (either 4,5,6 is fake, heavier)
4 = 5 (4,5 are real) => 6 fake
4 < 5 => 5 fake
4 > 5 => 4 fake
1,2,3 < 7,8,9 (either 1,2,3 is fake, lighter)
1 = 2 (1,2 are real) => 3 fake
1 < 2 => 1 fake
1 > 2 => 2 fake
The case 1,2,3 > 4,5,6 is similar to the 1,2,3 < 4,5,6 case
๐ก
Try the simulation game here
ย